Blog Layout

Article 2: Unpacking the Green Electricity Import Bid: A Retrospective from VPP Partners’s Perspective

October 4, 2024

This article was first posted on LinkedIn on 7 June 2024

The Inaugural Auction for 100MW Green Energy Sale to Singapore

In a landmark move towards sustainability, Malaysia extended an invitation to Singaporean bidders in April 2024 to participate in the purchase of Green Electricity. This initiative, part of the Cross Border Electricity Sales for Renewable Energy Scheme (CBES RE Scheme), is facilitated through the Energy Exchange Malaysia (ENEGEM) platform.

The pilot phase of this initiative will see up to 100MW of renewable energy, split into two 50MW blocks, exported to Singapore. This energy, harnessed from solar power plants and/or hydropower stations, will be bundled with Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs) and delivered on a flat 24-hour profile.

The delivery period is set for one year, from 1 September 2024 to 31 August 2025. The auction format is continuous bidding and pay-as-bid. The two highest bids win, with each bidder allowed to win only one 50MW block.

Let’s look at the some of the key considerations.


A Tight Timeline

The timeline for this Pilot Auction is notably condensed, with just over four weeks from the Expression of Interest to the Close of the Registration Date. This compact schedule may pose challenges for some retailers or generators in formulating their bids.


Eligibility Criteria for the Auction

Bidders are required to hold a retailer or generator licence. Given the tight timeline, it may deter external entities from partnering with these licensees to participate in the bid. Additionally, Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) and consortiums are not permitted.

Successful bidders are required to obtain an Importer Licence from the Energy Market Authority (EMA) in Singapore. The EMA has set certain requirements, which means not all licensees will be eligible to obtain the Importer Licence. This would result in a lower number of bidders for the pilot phase.


Setting the Bid Price

In 2024, the Uniform Singapore Energy Price (USEP) experienced considerable variations monthly, with average prices ranging from $107.70 to $288.70 per MWh. While the bid price encompasses all pertinent expenses in Peninsular Malaysia, such as RECs and system charges, it does not account for costs incurred on the Singapore’s side. These include the Capacity Charge by Singapore Power PowerAssets Ltd (SPPA) for the use of the interconnector and other market-related charges. Therefore, it’s crucial for bidders to take those costs into consideration and exercise prudence when determining their bid amount.


Securing Customer Load Demand

For smaller retailers, securing a customer load of over 50MW could pose a challenge, especially as the import commences on 1 September 2024. The inability to guarantee at least 100% offtake by this date could escalate market risks.


Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs)

As RECs are only granted upon the completion of the agreement, retailers may face challenges when targeting organisations seeking to purchase green electricity. Careful considerations are needed to ensure these organisations can comply with the relevant renewable energy reporting requirements and adhere to carbon tax obligations.


While this Pilot Auction may not be as attractive as initially hoped, bidders may view this pilot as a stepping stone to gain access to future electricity import projects. Malaysia has indicated that this is a pilot phase, and the import may potentially increase to 300MW. Regardless, this initiative signifies a significant stride towards a sustainable future, underscoring the potential of cross-border cooperation in promoting renewable energy sources.


Share on...

October 31, 2024
Originally posted on LinkedIn on 30 October 2024
October 4, 2024
Introducing Malaysia’s Corporate Renewable Energy Supply Scheme (CRESS) Malaysia is taking a significant step towards a greener future with the planned launch of the Corporate Renewable Energy Supply Scheme (CRESS) this September. This initiative, part of the GREENS MADANI Initiative, aims to enhance corporate access to green electricity and support the country’s energy transition goals. What is CRESS? CRESS is a framework designed to allow renewable energy producers and corporate consumers to arrange green electricity supplies through an open grid access model. This means third parties can supply or acquire electricity via the grid network system with a predetermined system access charge. Framework and Parties Involved Under CRESS, renewable energy producers and eligible corporate entities can negotiate and agree on terms for green electricity supply. The Energy Commission will regulate the program, while the Single Buyer (SB) and Grid System Operator (GSO) will manage market and system operations. Tenaga Nasional Berhad (TNB) will continue as the electricity utility supplier, ensuring consistent delivery of electricity.
October 4, 2024
To unlock the full potential of the growing Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) market, it's crucial to correctly assess returns to attract more investment in sustainable energy projects. With the rapid evolution of energy technologies and market dynamics, investors and developers alike face challenges in evaluating risk-adjusted returns, which are essential for securing funding and ensuring the financial success of these ventures. Without accurate and comprehensive assessments, projects risk being underfunded or failing to achieve their intended outcomes, stalling progress in the clean energy transition. Risk-adjusted returns for Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) projects measure the profitability of the investment while accounting for the risks involved. This is crucial because BESS projects can have significant financial and operational risks, such as technology failures, regulatory changes, and market volatility. Key Factors in Risk-Adjusted Returns for BESS Projects Revenue Streams : BESS projects can generate revenue through various means, including energy arbitrage, frequency regulation, and capacity payments. Each revenue stream has its own risk profile. Cost Considerations : Initial capital costs, operational and maintenance costs, and potential costs related to technology failures or safety incidents must be factored in. Market Risks : Fluctuations in energy prices, changes in regulatory policies, and competition from other energy sources can impact returns. Technological Risks : The reliability and lifespan of the battery technology used can affect the project’s financial performance. Incidents like thermal runaways or other failures can lead to significant losses. Financial Metrics : Common metrics used to assess risk-adjusted returns include the Sharpe ratio, which measures the excess return per unit of risk, and the Sortino ratio, which focuses on downside risk. A thorough project-level analysis is essential to accurately assess the financial viability of a BESS project. This includes evaluating technical merits, market conditions, and potential risks to optimise returns and ensure long-term success. How We Can Help At VPP Partners, we specialise in helping companies identify and quantify the risks associated with BESS projects. Our structured approach ensures that all potential risks are thoroughly assessed and managed. Here’s how we can assist: Risk Mapping : Mapping your opportunity against your risk appetite and risk tolerances. Initial Assessment : We conduct preliminary meetings to understand your project’s scope, goals, and context. Risk Identification : Using techniques like brainstorming sessions and expert interviews, we identify risks related to technology, market, finance, and operations. Risk Analysis : We perform qualitative and quantitative risk analysis using tools like Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) and decision tree analysis. Risk Quantification : We use statistical models and financial metrics to estimate the cost implications of risks. Risk Mitigation Planning : We develop strategies to mitigate identified risks, including preventive measures, contingency plans, and insurance options. Risk Tracking & Governance : Develop value at risk tracking and controls to ensure operations can be adapted as markets and technology changes. Implementation and Monitoring : We help implement risk mitigation strategies and monitor their effectiveness, ensuring your project stays on track. Reporting and Communication : We prepare regular reports and conduct meetings to keep stakeholders informed about risk management activities and outcomes. By partnering with us, you can ensure that your BESS projects are not only profitable but also resilient to the various risks they may face. Contact us today to learn more about how we can support your energy storage initiatives.
Share by: